Consistency is the defense of a small mind

Consistency is the defense of a small mind

David Eddings, a renowned fantasy author, is known for his epic series such as The Belgariad and The Malloreon. His works are beloved by fans for their intricate world-building, complex characters, and gripping plotlines. However, one criticism that has been leveled against Eddings is that his writing can sometimes be seen as formulaic and predictable. This criticism ties into the idea that "consistency is the defense of a small mind."

The phrase "consistency is the defense of a small mind" suggests that sticking to a rigid set of rules or patterns can limit one's creativity and imagination. In the context of David Eddings, this criticism could be seen as a valid one. Eddings' works often follow a similar formula: a young hero embarks on a quest, encounters various obstacles and challenges, and ultimately triumphs over evil. While this formula has proven successful for Eddings in terms of sales and popularity, some critics argue that it can lead to a lack of originality and innovation in his writing.

On the other hand, defenders of Eddings may argue that his consistency is actually a strength rather than a weakness. By sticking to a familiar formula, Eddings is able to create a sense of comfort and familiarity for his readers. Fans of his work know what to expect when they pick up one of his books, and they appreciate the reliable storytelling and well-developed characters that Eddings consistently delivers.

Ultimately, whether or not "consistency is the defense of a small mind" applies to David Eddings is a matter of personal interpretation. While some may see his adherence to a familiar formula as a limitation on his creativity, others may view it as a strength that sets him apart as a master storyteller. Regardless of where one falls on this debate, there is no denying the impact that Eddings has had on the fantasy genre and the countless readers who have been captivated by his imaginative worlds.