Half of these aren't even Machiavelli. Some are Plato, Thucydides etc.... doesn't anyone check these?

Half of these aren't even Machiavelli. Some are Plato, Thucydides etc.... doesn't anyone check these?

The quote "Half of these aren't even Machiavelli. Some are Plato, Thucydides etc.... doesn't anyone check these?" raises an important point about the misattribution of quotes to Niccolò Machiavelli. Machiavelli, an Italian philosopher and writer, is often associated with the concept of political cunning and manipulation, as outlined in his most famous work, "The Prince." However, many quotes that are commonly attributed to Machiavelli are actually from other philosophers such as Plato and Thucydides.

This misattribution highlights a broader issue in the study of Machiavelli's works and ideas. It is essential for scholars and readers to accurately attribute quotes and ideas to their original sources to ensure a proper understanding of the context in which they were written. By mistakenly attributing quotes to Machiavelli, we risk distorting his ideas and misrepresenting his philosophy.

Plato, a Greek philosopher, and Thucydides, an ancient historian, have their own distinct philosophies and perspectives on politics and human nature. While there may be some overlap between their ideas and those of Machiavelli, it is crucial to recognize the differences and nuances in their respective works. By lumping all these thinkers together under the umbrella of "Machiavellianism," we oversimplify and misinterpret their ideas.

Furthermore, the quote also raises the question of academic rigor and scholarship. It is essential for researchers and scholars to fact-check and verify the sources of quotes and ideas before attributing them to a particular author. By failing to do so, we perpetuate misinformation and contribute to the spread of inaccuracies in the study of philosophy and political theory.