It can't be nature, for it is not sense

It can't be nature, for it is not sense

"It can't be nature, for it is not sense" is a line from the poem "The Rosciad" by Charles Churchill, a satirical poet of the 18th century. In this context, Churchill is critiquing the artificiality and lack of authenticity in the theatrical performances of his time. He is suggesting that the exaggerated emotions and melodramatic acting seen on stage are not a true reflection of human nature or genuine emotion.

Churchill was known for his sharp wit and biting satire, and "The Rosciad" is no exception. In the poem, he takes aim at the actors and actresses of the London stage, criticizing their performances as over-the-top and lacking in subtlety. He argues that true art should be a reflection of nature, capturing the complexities and nuances of human experience, rather than resorting to cheap theatrics and empty spectacle.

By declaring that the performances he is witnessing "can't be nature, for it is not sense," Churchill is highlighting the disconnect between the artificiality of the theater and the reality of human emotion. He is suggesting that true art should be grounded in a deep understanding of human nature and should strive to evoke genuine feelings and reactions from the audience.

Churchill's critique of the theater reflects a broader concern with the state of society and culture in his time. He saw the theater as a microcosm of the larger world, where appearances and superficiality often took precedence over authenticity and truth. Through his poetry, Churchill sought to expose the hypocrisy and pretension of the elite classes and to champion a more honest and sincere form of art.