The commencement speech is not, I think, a wholly satisfactory manifestation of our culture

The commencement speech is not, I think, a wholly satisfactory manifestation of our culture

John Kenneth Galbraith, a renowned economist and public intellectual, was known for his sharp wit and insightful commentary on society and culture. In his essay "The Commencement Speech," Galbraith critiques the traditional commencement speech as a superficial and uninspiring form of cultural expression. He argues that these speeches often lack substance and fail to address the real challenges facing graduates as they enter the workforce and navigate the complexities of the modern world.

Galbraith begins by noting the formulaic nature of most commencement speeches, which typically consist of platitudes and clichés about hard work, perseverance, and the importance of following one's dreams. He suggests that these speeches are more about fulfilling a social expectation than providing meaningful guidance to graduates. Galbraith writes, "The commencement speech is not, I think, a wholly satisfactory manifestation of our culture. It is a formality, a ritual, a gesture of respect to the young and the future."

Furthermore, Galbraith argues that commencement speeches often fail to address the structural inequalities and injustices that shape the opportunities available to graduates. He notes that many speakers avoid discussing issues such as poverty, racism, and environmental degradation, choosing instead to focus on individual success and personal responsibility. Galbraith writes, "The commencement speech is a celebration of the individual, not a critique of the system. It is a pep talk, not a call to action."

In contrast to the typical commencement speech, Galbraith suggests that a more meaningful cultural expression would involve a critical examination of the social and economic forces that shape our lives. He calls for a greater emphasis on collective action and social responsibility, rather than individual achievement and personal ambition. Galbraith writes, "The commencement speech should challenge us to think critically about the world we inhabit and our place within it. It should inspire us to work together to create a more just and equitable society."